Question

What is the best way to revise the following sentence so it uses a pronoun in the nominative case? Lauren handed Sarah the keys after locking the door. She handed Sarah the keys after locking the door. Lauren handed her the keys after locking the door. Lauren handed Sarah my keys after locking the door. Lauren handed her my keys after locking the door.​

Answer 1

The sentence 'She handed Sarah the keys after locking the door.' is the best revision using a nominative case pronoun. 'She' serves as the subject replacing 'Lauren', and the sentence remains clear and concise while correctly applying pronoun-antecedent agreement and pronoun case rules.

Step-by-step explanation:

The best way to revise the sentence while using a pronoun in the nominative case would be: "She handed Sarah the keys after locking the door." In this revision, 'She' is the pronoun in the nominative case functioning as the subject of the sentence, meaning that it is the pronoun doing the action of handing the keys to Sarah. Using a pronoun in the nominative case avoids unnecessary repetition of the subject's name, Lauren, which was mentioned earlier in the text. By understanding pronoun-antecedent agreement, one can revise sentences to be grammatically correct while maintaining clarity and conciseness.

Case in compound structures is an important grammar aspect to consider. For instance, when we have compound subjects, we need to use subjective case pronouns, such as 'Antonio and I', whereas compound objects would require objective case pronouns, like 'between Antonio and me'. Similarly, in comparisons using 'than' or 'as', the implied words left out dictate which case a pronoun should take—subjective or objective.

Pronouns show possession when they demonstrate ownership, for example, 'their partying' or 'your approving', which illustrates that the partying belongs to 'them' and the approval is up to 'you'. This possessive case is used when the pronoun is modifying a gerund, which is a verb that functions as a noun in the sentence.

Answer 2

The best way to revise the sentence so it uses a pronoun in the nominative case is:

A. She handed Sarah the keys after locking the door.

Step-by-step explanation:

The nominative case or subjective case is used for a pronoun which functions as the subject of a verb. Take a look at the example below:

- She baked the cake. --> "she" is a pronoun, and it is the subject of the verb "baked".

The pronouns that may function as subjects and, thus, are related to the nominative case are: I, you, he, she, it, we, and they.

In the original sentence "Lauren handed Sarah the keys after locking the door," there are several nouns that could be replaced by pronouns. However, only one noun is the subject of the verb "handed," which is "Lauren". Thus, we need to substitute "Lauren" with a corresponding pronoun so that we will have a nominative case:

- She handed Sarah the keys after locking the door.