Final answer:
A trait provides competitive advantage if it enhances survival and reproduction. Hooves and high reproduction rates offer significant survival benefits. The Red Queen Hypothesis highlights the need for continual evolution to avoid extinction.
Step-by-step explanation:
To be considered a competitive advantage, a trait must allow the individual to survive better and reproduce more in that environment.
Horses find hooves advantageous because they are better equipped for environments with plains, which is suitable for their need to move quickly over open land.
In an environment that has undergone a major change such as a volcanic eruption leading to lower temperatures and sunlight, the species most likely to adapt and evolve rather than going extinct is an insect species with a high reproduction rate and a significant mutation rate.
Genetic variation is the factor of evolution driven by random events.
A high reproduction rate will most likely guarantee evolution rather than extinction when environmental changes occur.
The scenario that provides the best support for the Red Queen Hypothesis is the one where individuals of a sexually-reproducing species go extinct after a new predator is introduced, demonstrating the need to continually evolve to survive.