177k views
0 votes
Outsourcing (Make-or-Buy) Decision

Assume a division of Hewlett-Packard currently makes 16,000 circuit boards per year used in producing diagnostic electronic instruments at a cost of $27 per board, consisting of variable costs per unit of $22 and fixed costs per unit of $5. Further assume Sanmina Corporation offers to sell Hewlett-Packard the 16,000 circuit boards for $27 each. If Hewlett-Packard accepts this offer, the facilities currently used to make the boards could be rented to one of Hewlett-Packard's suppliers for $25,000 per year. In addition, $3 per unit of the fixed overhead applied to the circuit boards would be totally eliminated. Calculate the net benefit (cost) to HP of outsourcing the component from Samina-SCI.

User Mvermef
by
4.2k points

2 Answers

3 votes

Final answer:

Hewlett-Packard has the option to outsource circuit boards for $27 each, which would save $23,000 annually when accounting for the reduced fixed overheads and rental income. This is a Make-or-Buy decision, commonly faced in business strategy.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question involves a Make-or-Buy decision, which is a core concept in managerial accounting and business strategy. Hewlett-Packard is considering outsourcing circuit boards from Sanmina Corporation at a cost of $27 per board. The company needs to consider the cost savings and other financial benefits of renting out its facilities, as well as the reduction of fixed overhead costs if it stops producing the boards internally.

To calculate the net benefit or cost to HP of outsourcing, we need to compare the costs of making the boards in-house versus the costs of purchasing the boards from Sanmina and the additional income from renting out the facilities.

Currently, HP's cost to make 16,000 boards in-house is:

Variable costs: 16,000 boards x $22 = $352,000

Fixed costs: 16,000 boards x $5 = $80,000

Total in-house costs: $352,000 + $80,000 = $432,000

If HP outsources, it would spend:

Purchase cost: 16,000 boards x $27 = $432,000

Minus fixed overhead savings: 16,000 boards x $3 = $48,000

Plus income from renting facilities: $25,000

Total outsourcing cost: $432,000 - $48,000 + $25,000 = $409,000

The net benefit of outsourcing for HP, therefore, would be the difference between the in-house production costs and the outsourcing costs: $432,000 (in-house) - $409,000 (outsourcing) = $23,000 savings.

User Tomazzlender
by
5.0k points
3 votes

Answer:

If the company makes the units, it will save $7,000 per period.

Step-by-step explanation:

Giving the following information:

Make in-house:

Number of units= 16,000

Variable cost per unit= $22

Avoidable fixed cost per unit= $3

Buy:

Number of units= 16,000

Buying price= $27

Rent= $25,000

First, we will determine the total cost of each option:

Make:

Total cost= 16,000*(22 + 3)= $400,000

Buy:

Total cost= 16,000*27 - 25,000= $407,000

If the company makes the units, it will save $7,000 per period.

User Eridal
by
4.3k points