Question

Both of these texts highlight Napolean's defeat. Which statement BEST contrasts how these texts depict this event?

A) The Count of Monte Cristo describes a citizen's experience, while Napoleon Bonaparte describes Napoleon's experience.
B) The Count of Monte Cristo portrays Napoleon as the villain, while Napoleon Bonaparte portrays Napoleon as a beloved hero.
The Count of Monte Cristo details Napoleon's thoughts about the defeat, while Napoleon Bonaparte details Napoleon's actions.
D) The Count of Monte Cristo explains how Napoleon came to power, while Napoleon Bonaparte explains how Napoleon was overthrown

Answer 1

Option B best contrasts the depiction of Napoleon's defeat, with 'The Count of Monte Cristo' casting him as a villain and 'Napoleon Bonaparte' as a respected hero.

Step-by-step explanation:

Option B in your question provides the best contrast about how Napoleon's defeat is depicted differently in the texts: The Count of Monte Cristo portrays Napoleon as the villain, while Napoleon Bonaparte portrays Napoleon as a beloved hero. While one text may focus on the detrimental effects of his conquests on society and his eventual downfall, the other views him through the lens of a national hero, whose military campaigns and leadership marked a significant period in French and European history. Both accounts provide a unique perspective on the legacy of Napoleon — one from the standpoint of his negative impact and eventual defeat, and the other as a glorified, almost mythic figure who shaped the course of history.