160k views
4 votes
Develop a thesis statement that conveys a defensible claim based on "how do I love thee" by Elizabeth Barret Browning, then defend it through use of textual evidence, establishing a line of reasoning.

OR

Develop a thesis statement that conveys a defensible claim based on "The Sun Rising" by Jhon Donne, then defend it through use of textual evidence, establishing a line of reasoning.

User Raman
by
4.0k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Here is a potential thesis statement based on "How Do I Love Thee" by Elizabeth Barrett Browning:

Thesis: In "How Do I Love Thee," Elizabeth Barrett Browning uses a series of comparisons and metaphors to convey the depth and intensity of her love for her partner, ultimately demonstrating the power and transcendence of love.

In "How Do I Love Thee," Elizabeth Barrett Browning uses a series of comparisons and metaphors to convey the depth and intensity of her love for her partner. For example, she compares her love to "the breath, / Gentle at dawn, upon the forehead of the morning / Because it is for hope" and to "the rose that speaks of love / Quietly, in a eternal language." These comparisons serve to paint a vivid picture of the depth and intensity of the speaker's love, and highlight the fact that it is a force that transcends time and language.

Additionally, the speaker uses metaphors to further convey the power and transcendence of love. She compares her love to "an endless fountain" and "the sea," both of which are vast and powerful natural forces that suggest the enduring and all-encompassing nature of the speaker's love.

Overall, through the use of comparisons and metaphors, Elizabeth Barrett Browning effectively conveys the depth and intensity of the speaker's love for her partner, and demonstrates the power and transcendence of love.

Alternatively, here is a potential thesis statement based on "The Sun Rising" by John Donne:

Thesis: In "The Sun Rising," John Donne challenges the traditional view of the sun as a symbol of authority and power, instead portraying it as an intruding and oppressive force that disrupts the intimacy between the speaker and their lover.

In "The Sun Rising," John Donne challenges the traditional view of the sun as a symbol of authority and power by portraying it as an intruding and oppressive force that disrupts the intimacy between the speaker and their lover. The speaker addresses the sun directly, telling it to "get thee gone" and to "shine elsewhere." These imperatives suggest that the speaker sees the sun as an unwanted presence that is invading their private space and disrupting their intimate moment with their lover.

Furthermore, the speaker compares the sun to a "busy old fool" and a "saucy pedantic wretch," language that suggests contempt and disrespect for the traditional symbol of authority. This challenges the conventional view of the sun as a powerful and revered entity, instead portraying it as a nuisance that the speaker has no patience for.

Overall, through his portrayal of the sun as an intruding and oppressive force that disrupts the intimacy between the speaker and their lover, John Donne challenges the traditional view of the sun as a symbol of authority and power.

User Scott Wales
by
2.9k points