Question

Scenairo 1: Sid comes to school every day and disrupts. Some of his referrals were for cursing at teachers, starting verbal altercations, throwing things at other students. He also yrllls down the classmates were unable to focus when he's around. The school documents the behavior and works to get the student removed. At one of the last meeting his mother insisted he had the right to a free public withdrawn from the school.

is sid's right to a free public education more important than the rights of the teachers and other students?

how is sid infringing on the rights of others?

Are sid's constitutional rights are being taken away?

Scenario2: It has been one week since the shooting at the Fort Lauderdale airport by a gunman. A high school baseball team is on their way to nationals in Ohio. while going through the security checkpoint, the trams captain jokes that his friend has a bomb, The TSA agent pulled the entire team into a room to question them about the bomb. The boys miss their flight to Ohio and miss the championship game.

is this high school student's right to freedom of speech more important than the rights of this teammates?

how is the team captain infringing on the rights of others ?

are the teams constitutional rights are being taken away?

Answer 1

In scenario 1, Sid's right to a free public education is not more important than the rights of the teachers and other students to a safe and orderly learning environment. Sid's behavior is infringing on the rights of others by disrupting the class and making it difficult for them to learn. It is possible that his constitutional rights are being violated if the school is removing him from school without due process.

In scenario 2, the high school student's right to freedom of speech is not more important than the rights of his teammates to travel safely and participate in the championship game. The team captain's joke about a bomb infringed on the rights of others by causing them to miss their flight and potentially causing fear or anxiety among the other passengers and airport staff. It is possible that the team's constitutional rights were violated if the TSA agent detained them without probable cause.

Answer 2

1. No his rights are not being taken

2. the team captain is in the wrong and his teammates have a grater right to freedom of speech

Step-by-step explanation: