62.6k views
3 votes
Dbq essential question: how and why are the two leaders’ opinions about civilization both similar and different?

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

Churchill and the colonized people had similar beliefs in the importance of power and control, as well as recognizing the influence of Western civilization. However, they differed in their perception of civilization and the legacy of colonialism.

Step-by-step explanation:

Churchill and the colonized people held different opinions about civilization due to various factors.

Similarities:

  1. Power and Control: Both leaders believed in the importance of maintaining power and control over their respective territories. Churchill believed that the British Empire should continue to control its colonies to maintain political and economic dominance. The colonized people, on the other hand, believed in self-determination and the freedom to govern themselves.
  2. Western Influence: Both leaders recognized the influence of Western civilization. Churchill saw it as a positive force that brought progress and development to other nations. The colonized people, however, often experienced the negative effects of imperialism, including cultural erasure and exploitation.

Differences:

  1. Perception of Civilization: Churchill saw civilization through a Western-centric lens, considering it as a measure of progress, technological advancements, and political stability. The colonized people, however, had their own rich cultures and civilizations that were devalued and marginalized by Western standards.
  2. Legacy of Colonialism: Churchill believed that the British Empire had a civilizing mission and that the colonies would benefit from British rule. The colonized people, on the other hand, experienced the negative consequences of colonialism, such as exploitation, oppression, and loss of cultural identity.

These differences and similarities were influenced by factors such as historical context, power dynamics, cultural biases, and the desire for self-determination.

User Kind Contributor
by
4.9k points