We need to remember that a function is a relation between two variables in such a way that the INDEPENDENT variable has EXACTLY one DEPENDENT variable.
Therefore, if we add pairs of numbers to the set, we need to be sure that the value for x must have only, and only one dependent variable. Then, if we add to the set the following points:
(-6,1), (-1, 9), and (3, -2), we have two values for x = -6, x = -1, and x = -2.
And in this case, we do not have a function.
Then, if we add the values to the given set:
(-6,1), (-1, 9), and (3, -2) show that Erin's claim is incorrect.