Design A. The garden is 9 ft by 12 ft.
Design B. The garden is a circle of radius 5 ft
Area of garden A:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6c792/6c792b4948696ffa2933c9d049026d8e91c172b2" alt="A_A=9*12=108"
Area of garden B:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b2f51/b2f5154214864e35bf9ec79df7f44b097bb59d73" alt="A_B=\pi\left(5\right)^2=25\pi\approx78.54"
The areas are:
Design A = 108 square ft
Design B ≈ 78.54 square ft
Note: The area of garden B can also be expressed in exact form as 25π square ft