219k views
1 vote
Help pls help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Help pls help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-example-1

1 Answer

9 votes

Answer:

a) radius: 16.3 cm

b) area: 4122.7 cm²

c) it is an efficient tub, being within 1.1% of optimum area

Explanation:

a)

The volume of the tub is given by the formula ...

V = πr²h

Then the radius is ...

r = √(V/(πh)) = √(20000/(24π)) ≈ 16.3 . . . . cm

The radius is about 16.3 cm.

__

b)

The total surface area of a cylinder is ...

A = 2πr(r+h)

A = 2π(16.3 cm)(16.3 +24 cm) = 4122.7 cm²

The surface area is about 4,122.7 cm².

__

c)

The "most efficient" cylinder is one that minimizes its surface area for a given volume. Using calculus, it can be shown that cylinder will have its height is equal to its diameter. A good estimate of the optimum dimensions can also be found using a graphing calculator.

For the given cylinder, the height is 24 cm, and the diameter is about 32.6 cm. While that is not the most efficient, a graph of surface area versus height (attached) shows it is only about 1.1% away from the optimum surface area. The most efficient tub would have a height of about 29.4 cm.

((this tub area)/(optimum area) -1) × 100% = (4122.65/4078.82 -1) × 100%

≈ 1.075% . . . . difference of given tub from "most efficient"

While this is not the "most" efficient tub, we would say it is "an" efficient tub.

_____

Additional comment

In our development above, we have found radius as a function of height, as required by the problem statement. If we're to optimize tub dimensions, it is convenient to define height in terms of radius: h = kr, then find the optimum value of k for a fixed volume.

V = πr²h = kπr³

A = 2πr(r +kr) = 2πr²(1+k) = 2π(V/(kπ))^(2/3)(1 +k)

The derivative with respect to k is ...

A' = (some constant)(-2/3k^(-5/3)(1 +k) +k^(-2/3))

This is zero at the optimum, so we can simplify this to ...

0 = -2/3(1 +k) +k . . . . . multiply by k^(5/3)/(some constant)

2/3 = 1/3k . . . . . . . . collect terms, add 2/3

k = 2 . . . . . . . . . multiply by 3

That is, the height is twice the radius, or equal to the diameter for a cylinder with minimum surface area for a given volume.

__

In taking the derivative, we used the power rule and the product rule.

(u^a)' = a(u^(a-1))u'

(uv)' = u'v +uv'

Help pls help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-example-1
User Bobby Cannon
by
3.5k points