Question

1. Was George Pullman’s model town for his workers a good or a bad idea? Why?

2. Do you think the Pullman workers’ strike and the American Railway Union’s secondary boycott were both justified? Why?

3. Do you think the federal court injunction was necessary or did it go too far? Why?

Answer 1

Answer: It is undoubtedly true that the officers and directors of the American Railway Union did not want a strike at Pullman, and that they advised against it, but the exaggerated idea of the power of the union, which induced the workmen at Pullman to join the order, led to their striking against this advice.

Step-by-step explanation:

Answer 2

Answer:At the time of the strike, 35 percent of Pullman’s workforce was represented by the American Railway Union (ARU), which had led a successful strike against the Great Northern Railway Company in April 1894. Although the ARU was not technically involved in the Pullman workers’ decision to strike, union officials had been in Pullman and at the meeting at which the strike vote was taken, and Pullman workers undoubtedly believed that the ARU would back them. When the ARU gathered in Chicago in June for its first annual convention, the Pullman strike was an issue on the delegates’ minds.