Let's suppose the park is 1,000 ft long. In the case we use the scale of 1 inch to 1,000 feet the scaled map would be 1 inch long.
To find the length of the scaled map that uses the scale of 1 inch to 500 feet we can apply the next proportion:

Solving for x:

Therefore, the length would be 2 inches, which is greater than the first case. No matter what is the length, or the dimensions in general, of the park, the scaled map that uses the scale of 1 inch to 500 feet will be always larger.