The brightness of a source with luminosity L is given by:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/226ff/226ffbcbc6a20010260e9d6d35afbaab5f608954" alt="b=(L)/(4\pi d^2)"
Suppose that expression represents the original brightness if we increase the distance four times, then the new brightness is given by:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e1bb0/e1bb0e7b9c3a362c798f079dfe17a6fb9ca9ce43" alt="b^(\prime)=(L)/(4\pi(4d^)^2)=(L)/(16(4\pi d^2))=(1)/(16)b"
This means that the brightness will decrease by 16 times. Therefore, the answer is D.