Let's define what is happening in the senario given:
The catfish population is experiencing what is called allopatric speciation, where a portion of the population becomes isolated by geographical regions.
If this is happening, then the 2 smaller bodies of water will grow differently over time. They will have different resources and different biotic and abiotic factors that will drive the 2 populations of catfish on a divergent evolution.
Therefore, our best answer choice that matches this is answer choce B.