Question

5. Do you agree or disagree with Bolívar about Gran Columbia? How might South America be different today if his

vision had been accepted? Explain your answer.

Answer 1

I agree with Bolívar about Gran Colombia and believe that South America would be more integrated and influential if his vision had been accepted.

Step-by-step explanation:

I agree with Bolívar about Gran Colombia. Bolívar envisioned a united South America, with countries in the region coming together as one nation. If his vision had been accepted, South America today would likely be more politically and economically integrated, with a stronger and more unified voice on the global stage.

For example, Gran Colombia could have been a significant player in global affairs, shaping international policies and alliances to benefit the entire region. Additionally, the internal trade and cooperation among countries would have promoted economic growth and development.

However, it is important to note that Bolívar's vision was not accepted, and the region ultimately fragmented into separate countries. As a result, the individual countries of South America developed their own unique political systems, economies, and cultures.

Learn more about Bolívar's vision for Gran Colombia

Answer 2

The correct answer to this open question is the following.

I do not agree with Bolívar about Gran Columbia. I really respect Simon Bolíver, better known as the Great Liberator, and understand what his idea was in those early years of independence from the Spanish crown.

He thought that the vast territory called Gran Columbia would be stronger against any threats, including revenge from the Spanish crown if it remained like that. That is why he created a Constitution to rule that vast territory.

However, there were many differences and interests involved in those regions that conformed Gran Columbia. Let's remember that Gran Columbia was formed by the territories of Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador, and Panama.

How might South America be different today if his vision had been accepted?

Of course, it had been very different. Gran Columbia would have been a rich and powerful territory for the diversity of its people and natural resources. There would have been many industries exploiting raw materials and exporting them in favorable trade agreements due to the size of the production.