159k views
14 votes
Read the excerpt from “The Telephone: A Truer Tale.”

The story of the telephone’s invention in 1876 is one of hard work, determination, and triumph. Many accounts make it sound like a fairy tale. After all, it has a terrific happy ending in which the hero, Alexander Graham Bell, uses his astonishing new device to transmit the words “Mr. Watson, come here. I want to see you.” However, the true story of how the telephone came to be is not quite as happy as most imagine. In fact, it is not a tale of triumph at all, but one of tragedy. What’s more, the first words ever spoken over a wire could not possibly have been uttered by Alexander Graham Bell, because he was only two years old at the time.

Which quotation from the excerpt presents a counterclaim to the idea that the invention of the telephone was a triumphant event?

A. The story of the telephone’s invention in 1876 is one of hard work, determination, and triumph.
B. After all, it has a terrific happy ending in which the hero, Alexander Graham Bell, uses his astonishing new device to transmit the words “Mr. Watson, come here. I want to see you.”
C. However, the true story of how the telephone came to be is not quite as happy as most imagine. In fact, it is not a tale of triumph at all, but one of tragedy.

D. What’s more, the first words that were ever spoken over a wire could not possibly have been uttered by Alexander Graham Bell, because he was only two years old at the time.

2 Answers

11 votes

Answer:

A

Step-by-step explanation:

User Mayra
by
4.4k points
6 votes
He could not talk as he was only two years old at that time meaning that he was still a toddler
User Oksana
by
3.9k points