Question

Claim: Having a school library is important for students. It allows them immediate access to books so that they can study. Counterclaim: School libraries are unnecessary when there are public libraries nearby, especially since it is very costly to maintain a school library. Identify a rebuttal that would address the counterclaim.

Answer 1

A rebuttal to the counterclaim about school libraries being unnecessary could point out the tailored educational resources, convenient access, and specialized support school libraries offer, as well as their role in fostering community and essential academic skills in students.

Step-by-step explanation:

Addressing the Counterclaim

In response to the counterclaim that school libraries are unnecessary due to the presence of public libraries, one could argue that a school library provides tailored resources that support the school's curriculum, catering specifically to the students' educational needs. Moreover, school libraries offer a convenient and safe environment for study, and access to a librarian who can assist with school-specific research. The cost is counterbalanced by the value it provides in enriching students' learning experiences.

Additionally, school libraries may better support the needs of students who do not have easy access to a public library due to transportation issues or other barriers. Another point is that school libraries often have extended hours to accommodate students' schedules, which may not coincide with the operating hours of a public library.

A school library can also foster a sense of community and encourages reading and research among students, which are essential skills for their academic growth and personal development.

Answer 2

Not all students can get transportation to a public library, school libraries are used for more then just checking out books, they can be used for testing, having meetings, they can be a place for students to relax or hang out during their morning time.