Question

Bill and his family are visiting Sydney for the weekend. They live in Victoria and decide to have a week away during the summer holidays. They stay at the Shangri-La Hotel and as part of their package, receive a buffet lunch each day. On their second day at the hotel, Bill slipped on some grapes that were on the floor near the lunch buffet. As a result of the slip, Bill broke his ankle and was required to undergo surgery. He was off work for a period of 2 months and was unable to earn an income. Bill is suing for the total sum of $150,000. At the time of the fall, Bill reported the incident to the banquet manager who indicated they were not sure how long the grapes had been on the floor before the slip occurred. The incident report also noted Bill had consumed a number of glasses of wine before the slip.

Representing Bill as the plaintiff and the Shangri-La Hotel as the defendant, you are to make arguments to the Court as to who is liable in negligence for Bill’s injuries. You should argue the case referring to the relevant legislation and any case law. You should also identify the relevant jurisdiction in which the claim is brought.

Answer 1

In this case, Bill is suing the Shangri-La Hotel for negligence in causing his injury. The court would need to consider duty of care, breach of duty, causation, and contributory negligence. The relevant jurisdiction and applicable legislation and case law should be referred to in the argument.

Step-by-step explanation:

The relevant subject of this question is Law. Bill is suing the Shangri-La Hotel as the defendant for negligence in causing his injury. The jurisdiction in which the claim is brought is not specified in the question, so it is important to note that the laws regarding negligence and liability may vary depending on the jurisdiction.

To determine liability, the court would need to consider a few key factors. First, they would need to assess whether the hotel owed a duty of care to Bill. Second, they would evaluate whether the hotel breached that duty. In this case, the presence of grapes on the floor near the buffet suggests a potential breach. Third, they would examine whether the breach of duty caused Bill's injury. Finally, they would consider whether Bill's own actions contributed to the incident, such as the consumption of multiple glasses of wine.

It would be important to refer to the relevant legislation and case law in the jurisdiction where the claim is brought to make a thorough argument. Consulting with legal professionals who are familiar with the jurisdiction would also be advisable.

Answer 2

if that is shangri la hotel it's sure that there will be web cam for security and find the exact time that incident happen.also check where his family went. if he really drank wine then it must be someone from his family or it maybe someone waiter or other first understand what happen and try to combine it together you will know the result best of luck