106k views
4 votes
Read the following excerpt from The Princess and the Goblin by George Macdonald. Then, respond to the prompt that follows.

"You don't believe me, then!" exclaimed the princess, astonished and angry, as she well might be.
"Did you expect me to believe you, princess?" asked the nurse coldly. "I know princesses are in the habit of telling make-believes, but you are the first I ever heard of who expected to have them believed," she added, seeing that the child was strangely in earnest.
The princess burst into tears.
"Well, I must say," remarked the nurse, now thoroughly vexed with her for crying, "it is not at all becoming in a princess to tell stories and expect to be believed just because she is a princess."
"But it's quite true, I tell you."
"You've dreamt it, then, child."
"No, I didn't dream it. I went upstairs, and I lost myself, and if I hadn't found the beautiful lady, I should never have found myself."
"Oh, I dare say!"
"Well, you just come up with me, and see if I'm not telling the truth."
"Indeed I have other work to do. It's your dinnertime, and I won't have any more such nonsense."
The princess wiped her eyes, and her face grew so hot that they were soon quite dry. She sat down to her dinner, but ate next to nothing. Not to be believed does not at all agree with princesses: for a real princess cannot tell a lie. So all the afternoon she did not speak a word. Only when the nurse spoke to her, she answered her, for a real princess is never rude—even when she does well to be offended.
Of course the nurse was not comfortable in her mind—not that she suspected the least truth in Irene's story, but that she loved her dearly, and was vexed with herself for having been cross to her. She thought her crossness was the cause of the princess's unhappiness, and had no idea that she was really and deeply hurt at not being believed. But, as it became more and more plain during the evening in her every motion and look, that, although she tried to amuse herself with her toys, her heart was too vexed and troubled to enjoy them, her nurse's discomfort grew and grew. When bedtime came, she undressed and laid her down, but the child, instead of holding up her little mouth to be kissed, turned away from her and lay still. Then nursie's heart gave way altogether, and she began to cry. At the sound of her first sob the princess turned again, and held her face to kiss her as usual. But the nurse had her handkerchief to her eyes, and did not see the movement.
"Nursie," said the princess, "why won't you believe me?"
"Because I can't believe you," said the nurse, getting angry again.
"Ah! then, you can't help it," said Irene, "and I will not be vexed with you any more. I will give you a kiss and go to sleep."
"You little angel!" cried the nurse, and caught her out of bed, and walked about the room with her in her arms, kissing and hugging her.
"You will let me take you to see my dear old great big grandmother, won't you?" said the princess, as she laid her down again.
"And you won't say I'm ugly, any more—will you, princess?"
"Nursie, I never said you were ugly. What can you mean?"
"Well, if you didn't say it, you meant it."
"Indeed, I never did."
"You said I wasn't so pretty as that—"
"As my beautiful grandmother—yes, I did say that; and I say it again, for it's quite true."
"Then I do think you are unkind!" said the nurse, and put her handkerchief to her eyes again.
"Nursie, dear, everybody can't be as beautiful as every other body, you know. You are very nice-looking, but if you had been as beautiful as my grandmother—"
"Bother your grandmother!" said the nurse.
"Nurse, that's very rude. You are not fit to be spoken to till you can behave better."
The princess turned away once more, and again the nurse was ashamed of herself.
"I'm sure I beg your pardon, princess," she said, though still in an offended tone. But the princess let the tone pass, and heeded only the words.
"You won't say it again, I am sure," she answered, once more turning towards her nurse. "I was only going to say that if you had been twice as nice-looking as you are, some king or other would have married you, and then what would have become of me?"
"You are an angel!" repeated the nurse, again embracing her. "Now," insisted Irene, "you will come and see my grandmother—won't you?"
"I will go with you anywhere you like, my cherub," she answered; and in two minutes the weary little princess was fast asleep.

In a well-developed paragraph of at least 5 sentences, explain the differing perspectives of Irene and Nursie and how the author develops these perspectives in this passage. Use evidence from the text to support your response.

All I really need is at least a general outline on what to include and how to say/structure it in a way that compares the two instead of just summarizing what happened and how they felt about it. I suck at perspective comparisons someone help pls asap

User Glendaliz
by
8.6k points

2 Answers

6 votes

Answer:

In this passage from "The Princess and the Goblin," the author presents the differing perspectives of Irene, the princess, and Nursie, her nurse. Irene believes in the truth of her encounter with the beautiful lady, while Nursie doubts her story and dismisses it as make-believe. Irene is earnest and emotional, bursting into tears when she is not believed. She longs for validation and tries to convince Nursie by inviting her to witness the truth firsthand. On the other hand, Nursie is cold and skeptical, thinking that Irene must have dreamt the whole thing. She sees Irene's insistence as nonsense and refuses to entertain the idea.

The author develops these perspectives through the dialogue and actions of the characters. Irene's astonishment, anger, and tears convey her earnestness and desire to be believed. She seeks validation and wants Nursie to understand her experience. Nursie's coldness, dismissiveness, and annoyance highlight her skepticism and unwillingness to accept Irene's story. She prioritizes her own tasks and rejects Irene's invitation. The author also portrays Irene as a polite and empathetic princess, as she refrains from being rude even when offended. This further contrasts with Nursie's initial rudeness and subsequent regret. Through these interactions, the author effectively presents the differing perspectives of Irene and Nursie.

Your welcome! ;3

User Sekoul
by
8.2k points
4 votes

Answer:

In this passage from "The Princess and the Goblin" by George MacDonald, the author presents the differing perspectives of Princess Irene and Nursie regarding Irene's encounter with the beautiful lady. Irene believes wholeheartedly in her story and is genuinely hurt and upset when Nursie dismisses her account as a make-believe. She is deeply affected by not being believed, which reflects her innocence, sincerity, and the moral integrity attributed to a real princess in the story.

On the other hand, Nursie represents the skeptical and practical perspective. She initially doubts Irene's story, believing it to be a product of the princess's imagination or a dream. Nursie's skepticism arises from her experience and the expectation that princesses often engage in imaginative play. She is more focused on her duties and initially fails to recognize the emotional impact her disbelief has on Irene.

The author develops these perspectives by portraying Irene as a genuine and sincere character who embodies the values of truth and honesty. Irene's emotional response to not being believed, her willingness to forgive Nursie, and her desire to share her discoveries with her nurse all emphasize her innocence and goodness.

Conversely, Nursie's skepticism and practicality highlight her role as a caregiver and her concern for Irene's well-being, even though it initially comes across as dismissive. The author uses dialogue and the characters' actions to showcase these differing perspectives, ultimately setting the stage for Irene and Nursie to reconcile and for Irene to share her adventures with her great-grandmother. This passage serves to establish the central theme of belief, truth, and the contrast between the fantastical world Irene experiences and the skepticism of the everyday world represented by Nursie.

User Vishal Upadhyay
by
8.5k points