59.3k views
0 votes
Help this is due today.

Write a one page essay over the two views of our future as
presented in “By the Waters of Babylon” and “Uranium
235”. Discuss the biggest difference between the tone or
theme of the two works and be sure to discuss why you
think this difference exists. You will need to have a clear
introduction where you introduce the two works, authors,
the common theme, and your opinion. Also, have a clear
concluding statement where you leave the reader with a
valuable piece of advice that we should learn from these two
works. Include at least one quote from each work for
support and follow the quote with parenthetical citation
(Benet 262). Turn in for a grade!

1 Answer

3 votes

Answer:Title: A Tale of Two Futures: Contrasting Views in “By the Waters of Babylon” and “Uranium 235”

Introduction:

In the realm of science fiction, writers often explore the concept of the future, offering contrasting visions that range from utopian to dystopian worlds. Stephen Vincent Benet's "By the Waters of Babylon" and Ursula K. Le Guin's "Uranium 235" present two divergent views on our future. Both stories highlight the potential consequences of humanity's actions, but the difference in tone and theme between the two works lies in their portrayal of mankind's relationship with technology. While "By the Waters of Babylon" portrays a cautionary tale of abusing technology and the need for humility, "Uranium 235" reaffirms the importance of harmony between humanity and advanced technology to build a better future.

Theme and Tone:

The common theme in both stories revolves around the future of humanity. However, the tone diverges significantly. "By the Waters of Babylon" employs a somber and reflective tone, emphasizing the danger of man's arrogance and misuse of technology. The protagonist, John, embarks on a journey to the Dead Places, forbidden territories of the past, where he discovers the remnants of a once great civilization. As he witnesses the remnants of advanced technology, he becomes wiser and recognizes the importance of humility and respect. The narrator's voice in this story carries a heavy sense of nostalgia and melancholy, reflecting the gravity of human folly.

In contrast, "Uranium 235" adopts a more optimistic and hopeful tone. The story explores the relationship between humans and advanced machines, suggesting that unity and cooperation can lead to a prosperous future. Set in a society where machines perform most tasks, harmony between humans and technology is emphasized. Le Guin portrays a world where scientific advancements are embraced and enable the survival and growth of humanity. In this world, technology is an asset that can liberate and empower people.

Reason for Difference:

The difference in tone between the two stories can be attributed to the differing views on humanity's relationship with technology. In "By the Waters of Babylon," the author highlights the dangers of unchecked technological development, depicting a world where humans abuse power and become gods who control destructive forces. Benet warns against the hubris that accompanies unrestrained progress and advocates for humility, suggesting that the consequences of disregarding it can be devastating.

On the other hand, "Uranium 235" focuses on the potential benefits of measured and responsible integration of advanced technology. Le Guin portrays a society where humans and machines coexist peacefully, suggesting that embracing innovation can lead to a brighter future. The author invites humanity to celebrate the advancements achieved while remaining cautious of potential pitfalls, ensuring a careful balance between progress and ethics.

Conclusion:

From these stories, we can glean valuable lessons for our own future. "By the Waters of Babylon" cautions against the unchecked pursuit of technological advancement and the potential dangers of playing god. It reminds us to approach progress with humility and respect the natural order. "Uranium 235," in contrast, urges us to embrace the potential benefits of advanced technology while upholding ethical values that preserve human dignity and the environment. Striking a harmonious balance between technological advancements and human wisdom will be crucial in shaping a prosperous and sustainable future.

In forging our path forward, we should learn from both these stories, recognizing the transformative power of technology while remaining humble and guided by respect for nature, each other, and ourselves. As we embark on this journey, let us keep in mind that the responsible application of technology can shape a brighter future for all humanity.

Explanation: i hope this helps

User Ben Elliott
by
8.1k points

No related questions found