15.1k views
2 votes
Writing prompt: Write a compare-and-contrast analysis of how culture shapes the heroes in Heart of a Samurai and Black Ships Before

Troy. Use transition words in your draft to help clarify relationships of ideas.IN YOUR OWN WORDS PLEASE

User Cconnell
by
8.4k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Answer:

Culture plays a significant role in shaping the heroes in "Heart of a Samurai" and "Black Ships Before Troy," influencing their values, actions, and the challenges they face. A comparison and contrast of these cultural impacts on the protagonists, Manjiro from "Heart of a Samurai," and Achilles from "Black Ships Before Troy," reveal intriguing insights into how diverse cultural backgrounds mold their heroic journeys.

In "Heart of a Samurai," Manjiro, a fisherman's son from a small Japanese village, is shaped by a culture deeply rooted in tradition, respect, and honor. His upbringing instills in him a sense of duty to his family and community, which he carries with him when he embarks on a voyage that takes him to foreign lands. The transition from his humble beginnings to interacting with Westerners exposes him to contrasting cultural values, making him a bridge between two worlds. Manjiro's heroism is characterized by his adaptability, diplomacy, and a deep respect for both his Japanese heritage and the new world he encounters.

On the other hand, "Black Ships Before Troy" features Achilles, a formidable Greek warrior, born in a culture glorifying martial prowess, honor, and heroism. His identity is intrinsically tied to his exceptional combat skills and the glory that comes with them. The Iliad's epic battles and valor form the backdrop of his heroic journey. Achilles' strength and bravery in battle are revered in Greek society, and his actions are driven by a desire for fame and honor. However, Achilles' culture also highlights the human cost of war, leading him to grapple with moral dilemmas that question the true essence of heroism.

While both heroes are shaped by their cultures, their journeys differ in significant ways. Manjiro's heroism is born from a cultural exchange, where he learns to respect and incorporate elements of both Japanese and Western values. He becomes a symbol of unity and understanding between two cultures. In contrast, Achilles' heroism is more traditional, rooted in Greek ideals of valor and fame. He embodies the archetype of the mighty warrior, but his internal struggles reveal the complexities and consequences of such a heroic identity.

In conclusion, culture profoundly influences the heroes in "Heart of a Samurai" and "Black Ships Before Troy," shaping their values, actions, and the challenges they face. While Manjiro's heroism stems from his ability to bridge cultures, Achilles embodies the quintessential Greek warrior, both seeking honor but grappling with its implications. These diverse cultural contexts provide a compelling backdrop to their heroic journeys, highlighting the dynamic relationship between culture and heroism.

If u want something with “own words” puts more points , 13points are nothing for what I’ve helped, cheers!

User Kelly J Andrews
by
8.2k points