36.7k views
1 vote
What is one power US presidents currently have that you think they should not have? Make a persuasive case for why presidents should not have this power.

User Slyv
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Answer:

One power that US presidents currently have that I think they should not have is the power to launch a nuclear strike without the approval of Congress. This power is known as the sole authority to use nuclear weapons.

I believe that this power should be removed from the president for several reasons. First, the use of nuclear weapons is a decision that should not be made by one person alone. The consequences of a nuclear strike are catastrophic and far-reaching, not only for the United States but for the entire world. Therefore, it is crucial that the decision to use nuclear weapons be made by a group of people who are able to carefully consider the risks and benefits of such an action.

Second, the current system for authorizing a nuclear strike is outdated and does not reflect the realities of modern warfare. The sole authority to use nuclear weapons was established during the Cold War, when the United States was facing a clear and present threat from the Soviet Union. Today, the threat of nuclear war is more diffuse, with multiple countries possessing nuclear weapons and the possibility of non-state actors obtaining nuclear materials. In this context, the current system for authorizing a nuclear strike is inadequate and could lead to a catastrophic mistake.

Finally, the existence of the sole authority to use nuclear weapons creates a dangerous imbalance of power between the president and Congress. The Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war, but the sole authority to use nuclear weapons effectively bypasses this power and gives the president unchecked authority to start a nuclear war. This undermines the checks and balances that are crucial to our system of government and could lead to a dangerous concentration of power in the executive branch.

For these reasons, I believe that the sole authority to use nuclear weapons should be removed from the president and replaced with a system that requires the approval of Congress before a nuclear strike can be launched. This would ensure that the decision to use nuclear weapons is made with the careful consideration and oversight of multiple branches of government, and would help to prevent a catastrophic mistake that could have far-reaching consequences for the entire world.

No related questions found