Question

Suppose you are writing a research report on the original character of Mulan from a poem written almost 1,000 years ago. Which source would be best to use in your research, based on what you know about credible sources? a movie review about Mulan's character traits written by a movie critic an article in a historical magazine about how the mythology around Mulan is changing an interview with a literature professor who has researched early Chinese history a blog post from a woman in China who claims she is related to Mulan

Answer 1

The best source to use would be an interview with a literature professor who has researched early Chinese history. The document does not provide evidence to support a claim about the author's belief on the world with or without the Mongols. This document is not the most reliable source as it does not provide relevant information about the letter from the Pope.

Step-by-step explanation:

The best source to use in your research on the original character of Mulan from a poem written almost 1,000 years ago would be an interview with a literature professor who has researched early Chinese history. This source would be considered primary because it provides direct insights and expertise from a knowledgeable scholar in the field.

1. Based on the document, it does not provide any information about the author's opinion on whether the world would be better or worse off without the Mongols, so we cannot determine the author's stance from this source.
2. The document does not provide any evidence to support a claim about the author's belief on the world with or without the Mongols.
3. This document does not provide any information about a letter from the Pope or why it might be considered powerful, so it is not relevant to determining the reliability of the source.

Answer 2

For researching the original character of Mulan from a poem written almost 1,000 years ago, the most credible source to use would be "an article in a historical magazine about how the mythology around Mulan is changing."

Here's why this source is the most suitable:

Relevance: The article in a historical magazine focuses specifically on the mythology around Mulan, which aligns with your research objective of understanding the original character from the ancient poem.

Authority: A historical magazine is likely to have rigorous editorial standards and fact-checking processes, ensuring a higher level of credibility and accuracy compared to other sources like blog posts or movie reviews.

Expertise: The article is likely to be written by historians or experts who specialize in Chinese history or literature. Their research and expertise in the field make them reliable sources of information.

Academic Approach: A historical magazine article is expected to present information in a scholarly manner, supported by references to primary sources, citations, and a critical analysis of historical context. This can provide valuable insights into the original character of Mulan.

While the other sources, such as a movie review, an interview with a literature professor, or a blog post from a woman claiming to be related to Mulan, may provide interesting perspectives, they may not offer the same level of credibility and depth of historical analysis needed for research on the original character from an ancient poem.