104k views
3 votes
recall what you have learned in this portfolio to write an analysis of the texts ""genetically modified salmon can feed the world"" by yonathan zohar and ""say no to genetically engineered salmon"" by rick moonen. use the prompts to guide your respons

2 Answers

2 votes

Final answer:

Textual analysis of two contrasting views on genetically modified salmon reveals the debate over GMOs revolves around food security, safety, and environmental impact. Zohar supports GMOs for food production, while Moonen highlights potential risks, reflecting the broader discourse on the ethics of biotechnology.

Step-by-step explanation:

The analysis of the texts "Genetically Modified Salmon Can Feed the World" by Yonathan Zohar and "Say No to Genetically Engineered Salmon" by Rick Moonen presents contrasting viewpoints on the use and safety of genetically modified organisms (GMOs).

Zohar argues that GMOs offer a viable solution to global food shortages, while Moonen raises concerns about the environmental and health impacts of genetically engineered salmon.

Both authors touch upon the broader implications of biotechnology, specifically the ethical, legal, and social issues it brings to the forefront.

For example, Moonen questions whether genetically engineered crops are safe for the environment and if they might harm ecosystems.

On the other hand, Zohar sees genetic engineering as a necessary step to increase food production for a growing population.

Learning to analyze such texts involves understanding the objectives of each author and evaluating their arguments critically.

Lily Tran's thesis from a student sample suggests that we must strive for sustainable food systems, which highlights the importance of considering the environmental impact alongside the benefit of feeding more people.

User Forza
by
7.7k points
4 votes

Final answer:

The texts "Genetically Modified Salmon Can Feed the World" and "Say No to Genetically Engineered Salmon" present contrasting viewpoints on genetically modified salmon and its impact. Zohar argues for the benefits of genetically modified salmon in addressing global food shortages and promoting sustainable food systems, while Moonen expresses concerns about potential risks to human health and the environment.

Step-by-step explanation:

In their respective texts, "Genetically Modified Salmon Can Feed the World" by Yonathan Zohar and "Say No to Genetically Engineered Salmon" by Rick Moonen, the authors present contrasting viewpoints on the topic of genetically modified salmon.

Zohar argues that genetically modified salmon can help address global food shortages and contribute to sustainable food systems, citing benefits such as increased growth rates and reduced environmental impact. On the other hand, Moonen opposes the use of genetically engineered salmon, highlighting potential risks to human health, ecosystems, and wild salmon populations.

User Rambles
by
8.5k points