181k views
4 votes
From Edwidge Danticat’s short story “New York Day Women,” compose a persuasive essay that argues that Suzette is not ashamed of her mother. Provide textual evidence to support your point.

User DeeY
by
8.7k points

1 Answer

6 votes
In Edwidge Danticat's short story "New York Day Women," Suzette's complex relationship with her mother is a central theme. While some may argue that Suzette is ashamed of her mother, a closer analysis of the text reveals that Suzette's actions and emotions reflect a deep love and appreciation for her mother's sacrifices and resilience. Through various instances in the story, Suzette's unwavering support and admiration for her mother are evident.

Firstly, Suzette's willingness to accompany her mother to work and participate in the traditional Haitian practice of New York "day women" speaks volumes about her pride in her mother's role. Despite the challenges and long hours, Suzette joins her mother every day, demonstrating her respect and understanding of the sacrifices her mother makes for their family's well-being. This commitment to being by her mother's side showcases Suzette's solidarity and appreciation, negating any suggestion of shame.

Additionally, Suzette's deep understanding of her mother's struggles and her empathetic nature further emphasizes her lack of shame. Throughout the story, Suzette reflects on her mother's experiences, recognizing the hardships she endures as a day woman. She acknowledges the physical toll it takes on her mother, mentioning how her hands are "swollen, stiff, and aching." This empathy allows Suzette to see her mother's work as an honorable endeavor rather than a source of shame. She acknowledges her mother's strength and resilience, showcasing her deep admiration and respect.

Moreover, Suzette's reflections on her mother's identity and the legacy she carries highlight her profound pride. Suzette mentions how her mother embodies the "spirit of those Haitian women who, when they step outside their own doors, are transformed into 'America.'" This statement demonstrates Suzette's recognition of her mother's adaptability and the significance of her role within their community. Suzette's pride in her mother's ability to navigate between different cultural identities and succeed in her work is palpable.

In conclusion, the evidence presented in the text makes it clear that Suzette is not ashamed of her mother. Suzette's unwavering support, her deep understanding of her mother's struggles, and her pride in her mother's identity all serve as proof of her genuine love and admiration. Suzette's actions and emotions throughout the story reflect her unwavering commitment to her mother, dispelling any notion of shame. Their relationship is one characterized by mutual respect and support, solidifying the argument that Suzette holds her mother in high esteem and is far from being ashamed.
User Aline
by
8.4k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.