Final answer:
The best affirmative rebuttal using ideas from the negative position would be: 'Animals are unable to make laws, so they rely on humans for their protection.'
Step-by-step explanation:
The best affirmative rebuttal using ideas from the negative position would be:
Animals are unable to make laws, so they rely on humans for their protection.
By stating that animals are unable to make laws, it reinforces the negative position that animals do not have moral or legal rights. However, the statement also acknowledges that animals deserve protection, indicating an affirmative position in recognizing the basic interests of animals.