67.2k views
1 vote
(5 points) What is ambiguity with respect to parsing a

string w for membership in a language L generated
by a context-free grammar G? Why does it master? Can it be
mitigated?

User Challinan
by
7.7k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Step-by-step explanation:

Ambiguity in the context of parsing a string "w" for membership in a language "L" generated by a context-free grammar "G" refers to the situation where there are multiple possible parse trees or derivations for the same string. In other words, ambiguity arises when a string can be parsed in more than one way according to the grammar rules.

Ambiguity matters because it can lead to different interpretations or meanings of the same input string. It can cause difficulties in understanding and implementing the language specification accurately. Ambiguous grammars can also result in parsing conflicts, making it challenging to build efficient parsers or generate correct parse trees.

Ambiguity can occur in context-free grammars due to various reasons, such as:

1. Overlapping productions: When there are grammar productions that can be applied to the same input, causing ambiguity in the parsing process.

2. Left recursion: Left-recursive productions in a grammar can lead to ambiguity, as the parser may loop indefinitely or produce multiple parse trees.

3. Ambiguous language constructs: Certain language constructs inherently have multiple interpretations, leading to ambiguity. For example, an arithmetic expression like "2 + 3 * 4" can have different interpretations based on operator precedence and associativity.

Ambiguity can be mitigated through various techniques:

1. Grammar redesign: Ambiguity can often be resolved by carefully designing the grammar rules. By rewriting or restructuring the rules, ambiguity can be eliminated or minimized.

2. Operator precedence and associativity: Clearly defining the precedence and associativity of operators in the grammar can resolve ambiguity in expressions involving operators.

3. Left factoring and left recursion elimination: Applying transformations like left factoring and left recursion elimination can help in removing ambiguity from the grammar.

4. Disambiguation rules or semantic actions: Introducing additional rules or actions in the grammar to disambiguate specific language constructs can resolve ambiguity.

5. Using parser generators: Modern parser generators often provide mechanisms to specify disambiguation rules or preferences, allowing the parser to make informed decisions during the parsing process.

It is important to note that while ambiguity can be mitigated, it may not always be possible to completely eliminate it from a language or grammar. In some cases, a certain degree of ambiguity might be inherent to the language or its specifications.

User Fnllc
by
8.6k points