Question

The ending of "The Giver" can be interpreted two different ways: that Jonas and Gabe made it to Elsewhere and survived the journey OR that the last scene was a hallucination of Jonas' dying brain and they did not survive the journey. Explain which ending you believe is true.

Answer 1

I believe that Jonas and Gabe made it to Elsewhere and survived the journey because there is evidence in the text that supports this interpretation, such as the fact that Jonas heard music and saw lights, which suggests that they were approaching a populated area. Additionally, the author, Lois Lowry, has stated in interviews that she intended for the ending to be open to interpretation but that she personally believes that Jonas and Gabe survived.

Answer 2

"The Giver" by Lois Lowry is a thought-provoking novel that leaves the ending open to interpretation. While the author intentionally leaves it ambiguous, it is up to the reader to draw their own conclusion. Here are two possible interpretations of the ending:

Jonas and Gabe Survived: In this interpretation, Jonas and Gabe successfully made it to Elsewhere. The sled ride down the hill symbolizes their escape from the oppressive society depicted in the book. The warm lights and music Jonas hears at the end suggest the presence of a welcoming community or a better life beyond their previous existence. This ending implies a hopeful and optimistic outcome for Jonas and Gabe.
Jonas' Dying Hallucination: According to this interpretation, the final scene is a hallucination or a dying dream as Jonas succumbs to hypothermia or other dangers during their arduous journey. The soothing images and sensations represent Jonas' consciousness fading away, providing him with a peaceful and comforting experience before his death. This ending portrays a more bleak and tragic outcome.
Ultimately, the true interpretation of the ending is left open to individual interpretation, and there is no definitive answer. Readers are encouraged to reflect on the themes of the book and decide for themselves which ending resonates with them the most.