Answer:
Bundle Theory, in comparison to Soul Theory, presents a more compelling perspective on personal identity and is more likely to be true. Here are the reasons supporting this argument: Get homework help from proffrank01[at]gm ail. c om. Guaranteed quality to help you score maximum points.
Empirical Basis: Bundle Theory aligns with our empirical comprehension of the human mind and its psychological attributes. It postulates that personal identity is constructed through multiple interconnected attributes, such as memories, beliefs, desires, and experiences. This viewpoint reflects how we perceive ourselves and others, as a complex combination of psychological elements. In contrast, Soul Theory relies on the existence of an immaterial soul. This concept lacks empirical evidence and is not verifiable through scientific methods.
Continuity and Change: Bundle Theory provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the continuity and change in personal identity. It acknowledges that personal identity is not a static entity but an ever-changing process influenced by the development and modification of our psychological attributes. As our beliefs, memories, and experiences evolve, so does our sense of self. In contrast, Soul Theory struggles to explain how personal identity can adapt and transform over time.
Unity of Experience: Bundle Theory recognizes that personal identity is not contingent on a single, unified essence but arises from various psychological attributes. Our experiences, thoughts, and emotions form a cohesive narrative that shapes our identity. This viewpoint aligns with our introspective understanding of how our consciousness operates as an interplay of different mental states. In contrast, Soul Theory posits an underlying essence that remains constant, disregarding the multifaceted nature of human experience.
Compatibility with Neuroscience: Bundle Theory finds support in neuroscience research suggesting our sense of self arises from the dynamic functioning of the brain and its neural networks. Studies on memory, perception, and consciousness provide insights into how our psychological attributes are instantiated in the brain. The neuroscientific evidence supports the notion that personal identity results from the interconnected activities of the brain, reinforcing the plausibility of Bundle Theory. On the other hand, Soul Theory lacks empirical grounding within the realm of neuroscience.
Step-by-step explanation: