Carlisle Indian Industrial School was a boarding school for Native American children that operated from 1879 to 1918. It was established as part of the U.S. government's policy of assimilation, which aimed to "civilize" Native Americans by erasing their cultural traditions and forcing them to adopt Western ways of life.
In my educated opinion, I believe that Carlisle Industrial School could not exist in 2023 because of the significant changes that have occurred in our understanding of human rights and cultural diversity. The concept of assimilation is now seen as a violation of human rights, and the idea of erasing cultural traditions is viewed as a form of cultural genocide. Furthermore, there is now a greater recognition of the value of cultural diversity and the importance of preserving and respecting different cultural traditions.
In addition, there is now a greater awareness and appreciation of the importance of preserving the rights and dignity of marginalized groups, including Indigenous peoples. The legacy of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School and other similar institutions has been widely condemned as a form of cultural oppression and abuse, and there is now a greater recognition of the need to address historical injustices and promote reconciliation.
Overall, the existence of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School was a product of a historical context that is vastly different from our current understanding of cultural diversity and human rights. While the school played a significant role in the history of the United States, it would not be established in 2023 due to the significant changes in our societal values and understanding of cultural diversity and human rights.