299,735 views
26 votes
26 votes
A high school has a policy that students' phones must be kept away during class. A principal used

the school roster to poll a random sample of 50 students, and only 10% said that they ever had
their phone out during class. The next day, the principal observed classrooms and noticed that
approximately 25% of students had their phone out at some point during class.
Which of these is the most concerning potential source of bias in the principal's poll?
Choose 1 answer:

A high school has a policy that students' phones must be kept away during class. A-example-1
User Eranga Dissanayaka
by
2.7k points

2 Answers

5 votes
5 votes

Answer:

Out of these potential sources of bias, the most concerning the potential source of bias in the principal's poll is probably response bias.

Explanation:

There are several potential sources of bias in the principal's poll that could have led to the discrepancy between the poll results and the principal's observations. Some possible sources of bias include:

Self-selection bias: It is possible that students who were more likely to admit to using their phone during class were more likely to participate in the poll. This could have led to an overestimation of the percentage of students who use their phone during class.

Response bias: It is possible that students who participated in the poll were not entirely truthful in their responses. For example, students who do use their phone during class might have been reluctant to admit it, leading to an underestimate of the percentage of students who use their phone during class.

Sampling bias: The principal might not have selected a truly random sample of students for the poll, leading to a sample that is not representative of the entire student body. For example, if the principal only polled students from certain classes or certain grade levels, the results might not be representative of the entire school.

Observation bias: The principal's observations might not have been completely objective. For example, the principal might have been more likely to notice students who were using their phone during class, leading to an overestimate of the percentage of students who use their phone during class.

If students are not completely truthful in their responses, it will be difficult to accurately gauge the extent to which students are using their phones during class. It is important to try to minimize response bias as much as possible in any survey or poll.

User Gingo
by
2.8k points
15 votes
15 votes
D! Response bias is the one due to everyone’s mindset
User Dave Paul
by
3.1k points