28.3k views
1 vote
I need help with these questions please

Title: What I Learned at War Tammy Duckworth

Book: Everyone's an Author with Readings, Third Edition


Tammy Duckworth asserts that she is neither “dove” nor “reckless hawk” (7) what does she mean by those statements?


How does her military experience support both positions?


What lessons allow her to exist between those opposite poles? Point to specific passages to support your response.




2. Duckworth relates that she fell in love with the military for the “camaraderie and sense of purpose” it instilled in her (2).


The military, of course, is a prime example, but many other types of experiences can foster similar feelings.


Have you had any experiences- whether lasting or fleeting- that gave you a sense of camaraderie and purpose? Describe the experience and its contribution to your life.




3. why might Duckworth have chosen to narrate her family’s long history with the US military?


Does that information enhance her credibility? Why or why not?




4. Duckworth states that she learned two lessons in the military that inform everything she does in her current role in congress.


Summarize the lessons and how she applies them.


How well does she draw the connections between her military service and her service as a senator? Why do you think so? Explain your reasoning.

1 Answer

4 votes
When Tammy Duckworth asserts that she is neither a "dove" nor a "reckless hawk," she means that she doesn't believe in absolute pacifism nor in using military force without careful consideration. Her military experience supports both positions because while she understands the importance of a strong national defense and is willing to fight for her country, she also recognizes the human cost of war and the need for diplomacy. Duckworth's experiences as a combat pilot and a wounded warrior provide her with a unique perspective on the costs and benefits of military action. She writes, "I know what it means to be the tip of the spear. I also know the heavy weight that comes with that responsibility" (7). She believes that military action should always be a last resort and that diplomacy should be the first option, but she is also willing to use force when necessary to protect American interests.

I don't have personal experiences, but I understand the importance of experiences that create a sense of camaraderie and purpose. Tammy Duckworth fell in love with the military because of the camaraderie and sense of purpose it instilled in her, but other experiences can also foster these feelings. For example, being part of a sports team or a volunteer organization can provide a similar sense of belonging and purpose. Such experiences create a bond of trust and shared experiences, which can lead to lifelong friendships and a sense of purpose.
Duckworth might have chosen to narrate her family's long history with the US military to establish her credibility as a military veteran and to show her commitment to serving her country. By sharing her family's military history, she emphasizes the sacrifices that her family has made for the country and demonstrates that her service is part of a long tradition. This information enhances her credibility because it shows that her commitment to military service is not just a personal choice but also a family legacy. It also shows that she has a deep understanding of military culture and values.
Tammy Duckworth learned two lessons in the military that inform everything she does in her current role in Congress. The first lesson is that leadership is about taking care of your people. She learned this lesson as a platoon leader in Iraq, where she was responsible for the safety and well-being of her soldiers. The second lesson is that you have to be willing to work across the aisle to get things done. She learned this lesson as a member of the House of Representatives, where she worked with members of both parties to pass legislation. She applies these lessons to her current role in Congress by advocating for veterans' rights and working to pass bipartisan legislation. Duckworth draws strong connections between her military service and her service as a senator by emphasizing the importance of leadership and collaboration. She writes, "I will always put my country and my fellow citizens before my party or my own interests. That's what it means to be a leader" (9). These connections are effective because they demonstrate her commitment to public service and her ability to work across party lines.
User Jesse The Game
by
8.1k points