Question

Hello please I need help with this exercise.

1) Here is a thesis and the arguments. What are the arguments that would support the thesis and what are those that would refute it?
Thesis:
Living in the countryside is pleasant.
Arguments:
- In the countryside, we are bored.
- In the countryside, you can enjoy the joys of nature.
- In the countryside, there is more human warmth.
- In the countryside, we appreciate being alone.
- Country life is economical.
- In the countryside, cultural activities are limited.
- In the countryside, gossip is rife.

2) After making this classification, compose an argumentative text by developing the arguments classified above and supporting them with examples. Uses logical connectors to jump from one argument to another.

Answer 1

Thesis: Living in the countryside is pleasant.

Arguments in support:

• In the countryside, you can enjoy the joys of nature. The fresh air, the greenery, and the peace and quiet of the countryside can provide a refreshing change from the hustle and bustle of city life. For example, you can go for a walk in the woods, go fishing in the river or just sit outside and enjoy the scenery.
• In the countryside, there is more human warmth. People in rural areas tend to be more friendly and welcoming, creating a tight-knit community. This can provide a sense of belonging and support, which is often lacking in urban areas. For example, you can rely on your neighbours to help you out in times of need, and there are often community events such as fairs and festivals to bring people together.
• Country life is economical. The cost of living in the countryside is generally lower than in the city. For example, you can grow your own vegetables, have your own well or septic system, and have fewer expenses related to transportation or entertainment. This can help you save money and lead a more sustainable lifestyle.

Arguments against:

• In the countryside, we are bored. With limited access to cultural activities and entertainment, some may find the slower pace of life in the countryside to be dull and uneventful. For example, there may not be many options for nightlife, and there may be limited opportunities to engage with different cultures.
• In the countryside, we appreciate being alone. While some may appreciate the peace and solitude of the countryside, others may find it isolating and lonely. For example, if you are not part of a tight-knit community, you may find it difficult to make friends and connect with others.
• In the countryside, cultural activities are limited. With fewer museums, galleries, theatres, and cinemas, some may find the countryside to be culturally barren. For example, you may have to travel to the city to attend a concert or visit a museum.
• In the countryside, gossip is rife. With fewer people and more close-knit communities, it can be easy for gossip to spread quickly and for rumors to take hold. For example, if you are new to the area, you may find that people are quick to make assumptions about you based on limited information.

In conclusion, rural living may have its benefits, such as enjoying nature, experiencing more human warmth, and leading a frugal lifestyle, but it may also have its disadvantages, such as being monotonous, lonely, culturally restricted, and experiencing a lot of gossip. In the end, it relies on the preferences and demands of the individual.

Answer 2

1. Arguments that support the thesis:
- In the countryside, you can enjoy the joys of nature.
- In the countryside, there is more human warmth.
- Country life is economical.

2. Arguments that refute the thesis:
- In the countryside, we are bored.
- In the countryside, cultural activities are limited.
- In the countryside, gossip is rife.

Argumentative Text:

Living in the countryside is a topic of debate. While some people believe that it is a pleasant experience, others argue that it is boring and uneventful. However, I believe that living in the countryside has several advantages that make it a worthwhile experience. Firstly, in the countryside, you can enjoy the joys of nature. The fresh air, the greenery, and the peaceful surroundings can help you relax and unwind. Secondly, there is more human warmth in the countryside. People are more friendly, hospitable, and helpful, which creates a sense of community and belonging. Thirdly, country life is economical. It is cheaper to live in the countryside than in the city, as the cost of living is lower.

On the other hand, there are some arguments that refute the thesis. For instance, some people argue that in the countryside, we are bored. They claim that there are no entertainment options, no shopping malls, and no nightlife. Moreover, cultural activities are limited, and there are fewer opportunities to learn and grow. Additionally, gossip is rife in the countryside, as people tend to know each other's business and spread rumors.

However, I believe that these arguments are not entirely valid. For example, while it is true that there are fewer entertainment options in the countryside, this can be an advantage, as it forces people to find creative ways to have fun. Also, while cultural activities may be limited, there are still opportunities to learn and grow, such as by attending local events or taking up a new hobby. Finally, while gossip may be rife in the countryside, this is not necessarily a bad thing, as it can create a sense of community and help people connect with each other.

In conclusion, living in the countryside is a pleasant experience that has several advantages. While there are some arguments that refute this thesis, I believe that they are not entirely valid, and that the benefits of country life outweigh the drawbacks.