Question

How are the endings of “The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle” and “The Adventure of the Three Students” similar?

Responses

Holmes involves the police to ensure that the criminals in each case are brought to justice.
Holmes involves the police to ensure that the criminals in each case are brought to justice.

In each case, Holmes and Watson argue about the meaning of clues they find.
In each case, Holmes and Watson argue about the meaning of clues they find.

In both stories, Holmes learns from mistakes he made trying to catch criminals.
In both stories, Holmes learns from mistakes he made trying to catch criminals.

Holmes believes the person guilty of wrongdoing in each case deserves a second chance.

Answer 1

The correct answer is:

In both stories, the criminal is not punished through the legal system, but rather through other means.

In "The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle," the thief, John Horner, is not prosecuted because it is discovered that he was framed by James Ryder. Instead, Holmes uses his leverage to ensure that Horner's employer, the Countess of Morcar, doesn't press charges and gives Horner a second chance.

In "The Adventure of the Three Students," the culprit, Gilchrist, confesses to Holmes before any official investigation is launched. Holmes convinces him to write a letter of apology to the victim, who agrees not to press charges.

Therefore, in both cases, justice is achieved through unconventional means and not through the legal system.

Step-by-step explanation: