Question

Read one of your classmates' original posts, then compose a response post (at least 100 words) that does at least TWO of the following:

* Extends or adds to his/her point(s)
* Asks a clarifying question
* Disagrees (with reasoning and evidence) with the author's analysis
* Adds to the understanding of the analysis
* Offers constructive suggestions for improvement


Classmates post:
The film I chose to write about is titled “Soul Surfer”. It was directed by Sean McNamara and was released in 2011. This movie is not necessarily a classic because it has only been out for twelve years. The technical features of this film would be the editing in the surfing scenes as it cuts from up close shots to wide angle shots of the wave to give the effect of speed. Additionally, the visual effects are noticed in the moments of the shark attack. The appearance of the shark and the aftermath is impressive because it adds to the realism of the film. Another feature would be the ocean sounds and the overall beach environment including the wind blowing, and the sound of the water as the waves crash. The official genre of Soul Surfer is a docudrama because it is based on a true story but with added drama. The film is also rated PG.
 
            “Soul Surfer” is a film based on the true story of professional surfer Bethany Hamilton. The movie goes through Bethany’s life leading up to the tragic events of her losing her arm to a shark attack. Despite the incident, Bethany refuses to give up on her passion for surfing and works hard to make a comeback. With the support of her family, friends, and her constant trusting God, she overcomes the physical and emotional challenges to become an inspiration to others. The film delivers a powerful message about determination and resilience. A few themes and concepts mentioned in 9.7 of the textbook is seen in this film. The theme of the movie is relevant to real time now and the characters are authentic and show examples of real reactions to the events in the movie. There is a type of editing style that is used in the quick cuts between scenes. Additionally, one social issue that is highlighted is the issue of ableism, which refers to discrimination against people with disabilities. Bethany did not view her losing an arm as a disability and she proved that to the people who doubted her. One camera technique is the point of view shot. This is used in scenes when Bethany is surfing particularly when she is in a barrel wave. It is also used in the point of view of the shark moments before the attack.
 
            In evaluating the “craft” of Soul Surfer, it is noticeable that it is a well-made film, with strong performances from the cast and visually pleasing cinematography. The film effectively uses a range of cinematic techniques to convey its themes and messages. The positive message provides an informative movie about persistence and love. We can learn a lot from the characters in this film. Each character plays an important role as they support Bethany in her recovery. From research on other reviews it is described as a cheesy Hollywood movie. It does get a lot of criticism for it being a Christian movie about Bethany’s faith. This film portrays both Dionysian and Apollonian features however, there are more Dionysian themes. These themes are seen in the power of the ocean that is talked about. It is stated that surfing is a way of connecting with nature and experiencing the thrill of the unknown. These features align with the Dionysian theme. I would recommend this film to others as it is inspirational, motivating, and heartwarming.
 
  Hammond. (2011). SOUL SURFER. Back Stage, 52(15), 16–.

Answer 1

Thank you for sharing your analysis of the movie “Soul Surfer.” I agree with you that the film is well-made and conveys its themes effectively. One point that caught my attention in your post is the discussion of ableism and how Bethany Hamilton did not view her amputation as a disability. This raises an interesting question of how society defines disabilities and what kind of implications it has for people who have disabilities. In my view, ableism is often rooted in societal attitudes and beliefs that discriminate against people with disabilities, rather than the disabilities themselves. It is essential to recognize that disabilities do not define a person's worth or their ability to contribute to society.

I also appreciate your mention of the film's Dionysian themes, such as the power of the ocean, connecting with nature, and experiencing the thrill of the unknown. I think this aspect of the film adds to its appeal, especially to those who enjoy surfing or other water sports. However, I disagree with your comment about the film being described as a cheesy Hollywood movie. While it is true that some critics may have dismissed it as such, I believe that this film's inspiring message of resilience and perseverance is something that people of all ages can benefit from.

Overall, your post provides a well-rounded analysis of the technical and thematic features of the film “Soul Surfer.” One suggestion I would offer is to include more discussion on how the film reflects on society's attitudes towards people with disabilities and the role of ableism. By expanding on this point, you could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the movie's message and its relevance to our society today.