90.7k views
2 votes
Which account will make more money, an account that starts out with $4,500 with a 7.75% APR

compounded monthly or an account that begins with $5,500 with a 6.75% APR continuously
compounded? Calculate the two accounts for 10yrs, 20yrs, 50yrs, 85yrs.

1 Answer

1 vote

Answer:

  • second account makes more for the first 20 years; after 20.6 years, the first account makes more.
  • first account: 10 yrs: $9743; 20 yrs: $21096; 50 yrs: $214,137; 85 yrs: $3,198,369
  • second account: 10 yrs: $10802; 20 yrs: $21216; 50 yrs: $160,734; 85 yrs: $1,706,582

Explanation:

You want to compare the future values of two accounts after 10, 20, 50, and 85 years:

  • $4500 at 7.75%, compounded monthly
  • $5500 at 6.75%, compounded continuously

Compounded monthly

The formula for account value with compounding monthly is ...

A = P(1 +r/12)^(12t) . . . . . . principal P invested at rate r for t years

A = 4500(1 +0.075/12)^(12·t) . . . . . using given values for P and r

The first line of calculator output shown in the attachment gives the value after 10, 20, 50, and 85 years.

Compounded continuously

The formula for account value with continuous compounding is ...

A = P·e^(rt)

A = 5500·e^(0.0675t) . . . . . using given values for P and r

The second line of calculator output shown in the attachment gives the value after 10, 20, 50, and 85 years.

You will notice this (second) account has higher value up to 20 years, then lower value after that.

The account with the higher interest rate will make more money after the "break-even" period of about 20.6 years.

__

Additional comment

We have rounded the account values to the nearest dollar. For the purpose of value comparison, three significant figures would be sufficient.

The second attachment shows the different account values over the long term. You can see the higher interest rate really makes a difference.

The third attachment shows the shorter-term account values, and the "break-even" time period of about 20.6 years, when the values in both accounts are about $22,063.

Which account will make more money, an account that starts out with $4,500 with a-example-1
Which account will make more money, an account that starts out with $4,500 with a-example-2
Which account will make more money, an account that starts out with $4,500 with a-example-3
User Ayres
by
9.1k points