123k views
4 votes
Is it Ca₂C or CaC₂ which is calcium carbide? I am confused because Ca₂C is logical because of the balance of charges, but CaC₂ is what it shows on websites which is illogical because then it becomes a -6 charge. Thank you in advance if you have an answer! :D

1 Answer

7 votes

Calcium carbide is actually CaC₂, not Ca₂C. While it may seem logical that the formula should be Ca₂C to balance the charges, the correct formula is CaC₂.

In CaC₂, the calcium ion (Ca²⁺) has a +2 charge, and the carbide ion (C₂²⁻) has a -2 charge. Therefore, the overall compound is neutral.

The reason why it's not Ca₂C is because that compound doesn't exist. If we try to form Ca₂C, we would need two calcium ions (2 x Ca²⁺ = +4 charge) to balance the charge of the carbide ion (C²⁻ = -2 charge), which would result in a net charge of +2. Therefore, Ca₂C cannot form as a stable compound.

I hope that clears up your confusion!

User Bilal Akil
by
8.1k points