210k views
1 vote
The Lady or The Tiger

Directions: Please respond to the following questions. Unless otherwise stated, your responses to each question should be 3-7 sentences in length where applicable.
1. Describe the king's method of administering justice. Support your answer with details from the story.

2. Do you agree with the author that the king's method of administering justice was fair? Explain your thinking.

3. Why did the king think the princess's lover would be "disposed of" no matter which door he opened?

4. How had the princess found out what was behind each door? Support your answer with details from the story.

5. In your own words, describe why the princess had difficulty deciding which door to indicate to her lover.

6. How did the princess communicate which door to open?

7. If you were the princess, what option would you have indicated? Explain your thinking.

8. Was there ever a time in your life when you had to choose something you could not see? Maybe a gift, grab bag or a prize? Were you happy or unhappy with what you chose?

9. What conflict does the young man have? Are his conflicts external or internal? Support your answer with details from the story.

10. What internal conflict does the princess have? What motives does the princess have for each possibility? Support your answer with details from the story.

11. Describe a time in your life when you had to make a difficult decision. What were the possible outcomes? Were you happy with the choice you made, or do you wish you would have chosen differently? What would have changed if you had made a different choice? Explain your thinking.

1 Answer

3 votes

Answer:

The king's method of administering justice is to have the accused person choose between two doors, one leading to a beautiful lady and the other leading to a fierce tiger. The accused person's fate is then determined by the contents behind the chosen door. This method is said to determine guilt or innocence by "Providence." The details from the story suggest that the king believes in this method and sees it as a fair way of administering justice.

I do not agree that the king's method of administering justice is fair. It is essentially leaving the accused person's fate up to chance, rather than basing the decision on actual evidence and a fair trial. The fact that the princess's lover was accused without any concrete evidence and was forced to face this form of justice is not just. Additionally, the princess's role in the situation highlights the arbitrariness of the method.

The king thought that the princess's lover would be "disposed of" no matter which door he opened because he believed that the princess would not want her lover to be with another woman and would choose the tiger for him. On the other hand, if the princess wanted her lover to be with another woman, she would indicate the door with the lady. Therefore, the king believed that no matter which door the lover chose, he would be punished.

The princess found out what was behind each door by having a relationship with a person who had seen both doors. The story says that "she knew what lay behind each door."

The princess had difficulty deciding which door to indicate to her lover because she had conflicting emotions. On the one hand, she loved her lover and did not want him to be killed by the tiger. On the other hand, she was also jealous and did not want her lover to be with another woman. Therefore, she was torn between these two emotions and did not know which door to indicate.

The story does not explicitly state how the princess communicated which door to open. However, it is suggested that she would somehow signal or indicate to her lover which door to choose.

If I were the princess, I would choose the door with the lady. While I would still feel jealous and hurt that my lover was with another woman, I could not bring myself to choose the tiger and have him killed. It would be a difficult choice, but ultimately, I would choose the option that would spare his life.

One time in my life, I had to choose a mystery gift from a grab bag. I was nervous about what I would get and worried that I might end up with something I didn't like. When I opened the gift, I was pleasantly surprised and happy with what I received.

The young man's conflict is external, as he is faced with the king's form of justice and must choose between two doors that determine his fate. He is accused without evidence and must rely on chance to prove his innocence.

The princess's internal conflict is between her love for her lover and her jealousy. She wants him to be happy and alive, but at the same time, she cannot bear the thought of him being with another woman. Her motive for choosing the door with the tiger would be to punish him for his potential infidelity, while her motive for choosing the door with the lady would be to spare his life.

One difficult decision I had to make was choosing between two job offers. One offer had a higher salary, but the other offer was for a job that I was more interested in. I weighed the pros and cons of each option and ultimately chose the job that I was more interested in. I am happy with the choice I made, as I enjoy my job and feel fulfilled in my work. If I had chosen the higher-paying job,

Step-by-step explanation:

User Wolfuryo
by
8.3k points