Question

Emphasizing unity, we like to think that Americans thought the Articles of Confederation as aconstitution was inadequate and needed to be replaced by the US Constitution. We prefer to rememberthat most Americans were for the Constitution. However, initially more American politicians and votersopposed than supported the ratification of the document, the Constitution, drafted at the PhiladelphiaConvention. Should we just dismiss the Anti-Federalists as losers or should we remember their concernthat if we have a strong government and military and become wealthy and powerful we might lose somerights and liberty along the way?The original document drafted at the Philadelphia Convention did not include a bill of rights. Inopposing the ratification of that document, how were Anti-Federalists advocating liberty and rights?

Answer 1

The Anti-Federalists were not "losers" to be dismissed. They were an important part of the debate surrounding the ratification of the US Constitution and raised valid concerns about the potential for the new government to become too powerful and infringe upon individual rights and liberties.

One of the main concerns of the Anti-Federalists was the lack of a bill of rights in the original document drafted at the Philadelphia Convention. They believed that without explicit protections for individual rights, the new government could easily become tyrannical and infringe upon the basic rights and liberties of citizens.

By advocating for the inclusion of a bill of rights in the Constitution, the Anti-Federalists were promoting the idea of limited government and individual freedoms. They argued that a strong government and military could be used to oppress citizens and suppress dissent, as had been seen in other countries throughout history.

Overall, the Anti-Federalists played an important role in shaping the US Constitution and ensuring that it included protections for individual rights and liberties. Rather than dismissing them as "losers," we should remember their concerns and the important contributions they made to the formation of the US government.

Step-by-step explanation: