Question

(100 POINTS!!!) Write a letter to the judge persuading him or her to allow Pony, Soda, and Darry to remain together OR to take Ponyboy away from Darry and place him in a foster home.

You’ll need to use specific reasons and examples from the text to prove your point to the judge.

First, decide whether you feel the boys should or should not remain together.

Second, gather proof. Answer the question: should they remain together or not?
Remember proof is the details, examples, and reasons from the story.

Third, write an opinion statement (this is your thesis). No “I” in this essay. You want to be formal. After all, you are writing to a judge. It should be your topic (stay together or not) + your opinion about it = an effective opinion statement.

You will need three well-developed paragraphs in your letter. Yes, it has to be written like a letter.

(Doesn't need to be perfect, it'll give me an idea of how to format mine)

Answer 1

Dear Judge,

I am writing to plead with you to allow Ponyboy, Soda, and Darry to remain together as a family. As the story of "The Outsiders" by S.E. Hinton illustrates, these three brothers have experienced significant trauma and loss in their lives. They have been orphaned, and their older brother Darry has had to step up as the head of the household at a young age. Despite these challenges, the three brothers have a strong bond and rely on each other for support and love.

One key reason the boys should remain together is the positive influence they have on each other. Throughout the novel, Ponyboy is inspired by his brothers' strength and resilience. Darry, while initially harsh and overprotective of Ponyboy, ultimately demonstrates his love and care for his younger brother by sacrificing his own safety to save him from a burning building. Soda, meanwhile, serves as a calming presence and encourages Ponyboy to see the good in people and in himself. These relationships demonstrate the deep love and support the brothers have for each other, and suggest that they would be better off remaining together as a family unit.

Furthermore, the boys have already faced significant upheaval and instability in their lives, and breaking up their family unit would only add to their trauma. Ponyboy has already lost his parents, and the prospect of losing his brothers as well would be devastating. It is clear that the boys need stability and support, and remaining together as a family provides them with a sense of security and belonging.

In conclusion, it is my sincere belief that Ponyboy, Soda, and Darry should be allowed to remain together as a family. Their strong bond and positive influence on each other make them better off as a unit, and breaking up their family would only add to their already significant trauma. I implore you to consider the best interests of these three boys and allow them to stay together.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]

Step-by-step explanation: