Answer: It depends which texts you are analysing.
Explanation: You need to write what the two arguments are about, then what they claim. Then, you need to write what the authors disagree about and why - you'll need a quote from each text that supports your point. Talk about what's wrong with each argument and what could be done to improve them - make sure to use quotes for this too! Finally, use quotes to explain which argument uses literary devices better (in your opinion.)
Hope that helped!