Paine's argument against the idea of reconciliation with Great Britain in the excerpt from Common Sense is very effective. He uses valid and sufficient reasons and evidence to support his argument for separation from Great Britain. Paine argues that Great Britain has shown itself to be a tyrannical power that has repeatedly abused and oppressed the American colonies. He claims that reconciliation is not a viable option because the British government is fundamentally corrupt and cannot be trusted to act in the best interests of the American people.
Paine supports his argument with a variety of evidence, including historical examples of British oppression, such as the expulsion of the Acadians and the treatment of Irish Catholics. He also argues that reconciliation would be impossible because the British government would never agree to the terms necessary for a fair and just settlement. Paine's argument is persuasive because it is based on concrete evidence and logical reasoning. He is able to clearly articulate the reasons why reconciliation is not a viable option and why separation from Great Britain is necessary.
Overall, Paine's argument in Common Sense is highly effective. He uses a variety of evidence and reasoning to support his claim that separation from Great Britain is necessary. His argument is grounded in concrete examples of British oppression and tyranny, and he is able to demonstrate that reconciliation is not a viable option. Paine's argument played a critical role in convincing many Americans to support the cause of independence and to fight for their freedom.