54.0k views
3 votes
How is the message from the song both similar and different from Kincaid's poem "Girl," published in the United States in 1978, but set in Antigua, a Caribbean island of the West Indies?

The Song on YT: Little Big Town's song "The Daughters,"

User Happyhuman
by
8.2k points

1 Answer

1 vote

Answer:

Step-by-step explanation:

Both "The Daughters" and Kincaid's poem "Girl" deal with the expectations and limitations placed on young women. "Girl" is a dialogue between a mother and daughter, where the mother gives a long list of instructions and advice on how to behave as a proper and respectable woman in Antiguan society. Similarly, "The Daughters" speaks to the pressure that young women face to conform to societal expectations and be "perfect" in appearance and behavior.

However, there are also significant differences between the two works. "Girl" specifically focuses on the cultural and societal norms of Antiguan society, while "The Daughters" speaks to a more universal experience of growing up as a girl in a patriarchal society. Additionally, while "Girl" takes a more didactic tone, with the mother giving explicit instructions, "The Daughters" takes a more reflective and introspective approach, exploring the emotional toll that societal pressures can take on young women.

User Lior Ohana
by
8.1k points