13.6k views
5 votes
20 Points:

How many ways are there to form a 5 person committee from 2 freshmen, 3 sophomores, 2 juniors, and 2 seniors if there cannot be the same number of juniors and seniors? Note that people are distinct.

1 Answer

6 votes

Answer: 81

=================================================

Step-by-step explanation:

2 freshmen + 3 sophomores + 2 juniors + 2 seniors = 9 students total.

Let's consider the cases where we have the same number of juniors and seniors. We'll then take the complement of this to get the final answer.

  • Case A will look at having 1 of each junior and senior.
  • Case B will look at having 2 each of juniors and seniors.

-----------

Case A: There is 1 junior and 1 senior

There are 2 ways to pick a junior and 2 ways to pick a senior. That's 2*2 = 4 ways so far.

Then we have 9-4 = 5 students left to pick from (i.e. 2 freshmen+3 sophomores = 5 students left) and we have 5-2 = 3 seats to fill. Order doesn't matter on the committee since each person has equal rank.

We use the nCr combination formula.

n = 5 students

r = 3 seats to fill

n C r = (n!)/(r!(n-r)!)

5 C 3 = (5!)/(3!*(5-3)!)

5 C 3 = (5!)/(3!*2!)

5 C 3 = (5*4*3!)/(3!*2!)

5 C 3 = (5*4)/(2!)

5 C 3 = (5*4)/(2*1)

5 C 3 = (20)/(2)

5 C 3 = 10

There are 10 ways to fill the remaining 3 seats when we pick from the freshmen and sophomores only.

To recap everything so far:

  • 4 ways to pick the 1 junior and 1 senior
  • 10 ways to pick the 3 other students (freshmen + sophomores)

Therefore, we have 4*10 = 40 different combinations possible for case A. We'll refer to this value later.

-----------

Case B: We pick 2 juniors and 2 seniors

Since there 2 juniors to pick from, and 2 junior seats to fill, there's only 1 way to do this. Likewise, there's only 1 way to pick the 2 seniors to fill the 2 seats.

In total so far there is 1*1 = 1 way to pick the 2 juniors and 2 seniors in any order you like.

Then we have 9-4 = 5 students left that are freshmen or sophomores. This is the number of choices we have for the final 5th seat.

We have 1*5 = 5 ways to have case B happen.

----------

Summary so far:

  • 40 ways to do case A
  • 5 ways to do case B
  • 40+5 = 45 ways to do either case.

There are 45 ways to have the same number of juniors as seniors (either 1 of each or 2 of each).

Now we must calculate the number of total combinations possible on this committee. We'll turn to the nCr formula again.

n = 9 students

r = 5 seats

n C r = (n!)/(r!(n-r)!)

9 C 5 = (9!)/(5!*(9-5)!)

9 C 5 = (9!)/(5!*4!)

9 C 5 = (9*8*7*6*5!)/(5!*4!)

9 C 5 = (9*8*7*6)/(4!)

9 C 5 = (9*8*7*6)/(4*3*2*1)

9 C 5 = (3024)/(24)

9 C 5 = 126

There are 126 different five-person committees possible.

Of those 126 committees, 45 of them consist of cases where we have the same number of juniors and seniors.

That must mean there are 126-45 = 81 combinations where we do not have the same number of juniors and seniors. This is where the concept of "complement" comes in.

User Cas Bloem
by
7.6k points