118k views
2 votes
When Qian-long expected Lord George Macartney to kowtow, what do you think Macartney should have done? Why? Think about: culture differences, effect on trading, the kowtow ritual and political correctness.

1 Answer

5 votes

Answer:

Lord George Macartney was a representative of the British Empire and was sent to China in 1793 to establish a trading relationship between China and Britain. When he met with Qian-long, the emperor of China, he was expected to perform the kowtow ritual, which involved kneeling and touching one's forehead to the ground as a sign of respect to the emperor.

Given the cultural differences between China and Britain, Macartney was faced with a difficult decision. On the one hand, if he had performed the kowtow, he would have shown respect for the emperor and his culture, which could have potentially led to a more favorable trading relationship between China and Britain. On the other hand, if he had refused to perform the kowtow, he would have been asserting the independence and sovereignty of the British Empire, which could have also led to a more equal and respectful relationship between the two countries.

Ultimately, Macartney chose not to perform the kowtow, and instead made a bow as a sign of respect. This decision reflected the political correctness of his time and his culture, which valued the dignity and sovereignty of the individual and their nation. Moreover, it allowed him to negotiate from a position of equality, rather than subservience, which could have been an advantage in future trade negotiations.

However, Macartney's refusal to perform the kowtow ritual may have offended Qian-long and the Chinese officials, which could have had negative consequences for the trading relationship between China and Britain. In the end, it is difficult to say what the best decision would have been, given the complex cultural, political, and economic factors involved.

User Minh Pham
by
8.3k points