68,886 views
11 votes
11 votes
Compare and Contrast "Balboa" By Sabina Murray and William Bradford's "Of Plymouth Plantation"

Compare and Contrast "Balboa" By Sabina Murray and William Bradford's &quot-example-1
User AndyMoore
by
3.1k points

1 Answer

9 votes
9 votes

Answer:

"Balboa" by Sabina Murray and William Bradford's "Of Plymouth Plantation" are two texts that explore different aspects of history and human experience.

Sabina Murray's "Balboa" is a historical fiction on the life of the explorer Vasco Núñez de Balboa, who is credited with discovering the Pacific Ocean. The intended purpose of this text is to tell a story about Balboa's life and to explore themes of exploration, colonization, and the human experience. Murray is successful in achieving this intended purpose through the use of imaginative storytelling and literary devices. The text is structured as a narrative and is written in a style that is evocative and engaging. Through the character of Vasco Núñez de Balboa, Murray is able to explore themes of exploration and colonization and to provide insight into the motivations and experiences of the explorer.

William Bradford's "Of Plymouth Plantation" is a historical account written by one of the leaders of the Pilgrims who settled in Plymouth, Massachusetts in the early 17th century. The intended purpose of this text is to provide a factual and detailed account of the experiences and events of the Pilgrims. Bradford is successful in achieving this intended purpose through the use of precise and detailed language. The text is structured as a diary or journal, with Bradford providing a chronological account of the Pilgrims' journey to the New World and their experiences in Plymouth. Through his writing, Bradford is able to provide a wealth of information about the Pilgrims' experiences and to give readers a sense of what life was like for the settlers in the early days of the colony.

Another difference between the texts is their uses of literary devices. In "Balboa," Sabina Murray uses imagery and descriptive language to create vivid and evocative scenes. She also uses symbolism to represent the themes and ideas that she is exploring in the text, while in "Of Plymouth Plantation," William Bradford uses literary devices to a lesser extent, as the text is primarily a historical account rather than a work of fiction. However, Bradford does use some literary devices to enhance the clarity and effectiveness of his writing. For example, he uses descriptive language and imagery to help readers visualize the scenes and events that he is describing. He also uses rhetorical devices, such as repetition and parallel structure, to help emphasize important points and ideas.

The two author's works also have difference in how they influence the reader's perception of the world. For example, Murray's depiction of Balboa may influence how readers perceive themes of exploration and colonization. By exploring the motivations and desires of the explorer, Murray presents a more nuanced view of these themes and allows readers to consider them from multiple perspectives. William Bradford's portrayal of the Pilgrims and their experiences in "Of Plymouth Plantation," may also influence how readers perceive the events and occurrences of the time period.

A large difference between the two texts is their tone and style. "Balboa" is written in a more imaginative and literary style, with the author using fictionalized accounts and literary devices to tell the story of Balboa's life. "Of Plymouth Plantation," on the other hand, is written in a more factual and historical style, with Bradford providing a detailed account of the events and experiences of the Pilgrims.

Despite these differences, both "Balboa" and "Of Plymouth Plantation" explore themes of exploration, colonization, and the human experience. In "Balboa," the character of Vasco Núñez de Balboa represents the desire to explore and discover new worlds, and the text touches on themes of colonization and the impact of European expansion on indigenous peoples. "Of Plymouth Plantation" also deals with these themes, as the Pilgrims' journey to the New World and their settlement in Plymouth represent the expansion of European influence and the challenges of building a new society in a foreign land.

Overall, "Balboa" and "Of Plymouth Plantation" are two texts that explore different aspects of history and human experience, and while they have many differences in many areas such as intended purpose, genre, use of literary devices, and influence left on the reader, the two stories also share much in common.

OK i did it!!! 700 words written for stinky lazy internet person!! WOOOOOO the above essay covers everythinggggg!! comparement and contrastment, intended purpose, genre, literary devices, figures of speech, story elements, and influence on the reader are allll covered herrrrrreeeeeee wpopppoierpoitutopeigjpotihj

User Kyle Emmanuel
by
3.2k points