Question

Reflect on the Brobdingnagian king’s reaction to Gulliver’s offer of gunpowder. Most societies consider gunpowder a significant, albeit dangerous, invention. Why does the king dismiss Gulliver’s offer? Write an essay describing an innovation or creation in your own world that you would have rejected if you had the power to do so. Include an explanation of why you chose this specific development and what the modern world might look like without it.

Answer 1

In Jonathan Swift's novel "Gulliver's Travels," Gulliver finds himself in the land of the giants, known as Brobdingnag. During his stay, he attempts to impress the king with his knowledge and skills, including his offer of gunpowder. However, the king dismisses his offer, stating that the use of gunpowder would lead to the destruction of humanity. This scene highlights the Brobdingnagian king's wisdom and foresight, as he understands the destructive nature of such an invention.

Similarly, there have been many innovations and creations in our world that have had significant impacts, both positive and negative. If given the power to reject one of these developments, I would choose to reject plastic.

Plastic was first developed in the early 20th century and has since become a ubiquitous material in our modern world. It is used in everything from packaging and consumer goods to medical equipment and construction materials. However, its widespread use has led to severe environmental consequences, including pollution of the oceans and landfills.

Without plastic, the modern world would look vastly different. The packaging and transportation of goods would have to rely on alternative materials, such as paper or biodegradable plastics. Medical equipment and electronics would need to be made from other materials, which may not be as durable or cost-effective as plastic. The construction industry would also have to find alternatives to plastic-based materials, which could impact the efficiency and affordability of building projects.

However, rejecting plastic would also have many benefits. The environment would be much healthier, with fewer plastic waste products polluting the oceans and landfills. The development of alternative materials could also lead to new innovations and industries, as companies work to find more sustainable solutions.

In conclusion, the Brobdingnagian king's reaction to Gulliver's offer of gunpowder highlights the importance of understanding the potential impacts of new innovations and creations. If given the power to reject one such development in our modern world, I would choose to reject plastic due to its significant environmental impact. While the rejection of plastic would undoubtedly have its challenges, it would also lead to a more sustainable and healthier world in the long run.