Question

Yuki was worried about telling her daughter, Mie, of the dreams she had for herself when she was younger. "She worried that if she told her the truth, it might influence Mie in the wrong way. Women had a hard life if they chose not to marry and be a devoted wife and mother - and she wanted Mie to have a comfortable life." Was it a wise choice for Yuki not to disclose her own childhood dreams to Mie? Support your opinion with passages from the text.

Answer 1

The textual evidence suggests that withholding personal aspirations, such as Yuki's dreams, may lead to regret or misconstrued relationships, while transparency can prevent future pain and disillusionment.

Step-by-step explanation:

The decision of whether Yuki should disclose her own childhood dreams to Mie is complex and contingent on various factors, including cultural norms and the potential impact on Mie's future. However, considering the passages provided from various texts, we can infer that keeping such personal aspirations concealed might lead to regret or misunderstandings. For example, it is expressed in the text 'Truth often finds its way to the mind close muffled in robes of sleep', suggesting that suppressed truths can manifest in other ways and impact relationships. Moreover, the passage showing a wife's life deeply intertwined with her husband's fate, to the extent of ritual su ic ide, highlights the severity of the consequences a woman might face if diverging from societal expectations. On the other hand, the importance of having frank and open conversations is revealed when misunderstandings arise from lack of communication, as shown in the passage 'Perhaps he was afraid to tell you.' Additionally, the excerpts from the texts suggest that transparency can avert the potential for future pain and disillusionment that might stem from illusions of a life shaped solely by another's expectations or societal pressures.