269,754 views
35 votes
35 votes
Analyze Jack and Algernon's discussion about eating

muffins. How does it contribute to commentary on
seriousness, pleasure and manners in the play? Respond
in at least 4-5 sentences. Please use evidence from the
text in your response!

User Fazle Rabbi
by
3.1k points

1 Answer

18 votes
18 votes

In The Importance of Being Earnest, Jack and Algernon have a discussion about eating muffins that contributes to commentary on seriousness, pleasure, and manners in the play. The conversation begins when Algernon expresses surprise that Jack is eating muffins for breakfast, to which Jack replies that he is not eating them for breakfast, but rather as a "pleasure" at any time of the day.

This exchange reveals the characters' attitudes towards pleasure and enjoyment. Algernon, who is known for his carefree and hedonistic lifestyle, sees no problem with eating muffins for breakfast and sees pleasure as a valid pursuit in and of itself. Jack, on the other hand, is more reserved and serious, and sees pleasure as something to be indulged in only in moderation.

The conversation also touches on the theme of manners and social norms. Algernon criticizes Jack for eating muffins with his fingers, which he considers to be a breach of good manners. Jack, however, dismisses this criticism and argues that he is simply enjoying the muffins in the way that he finds most pleasurable.

Overall, the discussion about muffins reveals the characters' attitudes towards pleasure, seriousness, and manners in the play. It highlights the different ways in which they approach these issues and serves as a commentary on the social norms and expectations of their time.

User MarkD
by
2.7k points