235k views
1 vote
What are some of the ways in which Nancy Scheper Hughes pushes accepted ethical boundaries in her anthropological fieldwork?

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

Nancy Scheper-Hughes is noted for pushing accepted ethical boundaries in anthropological fieldwork by advocating for 'good enough ethnography' which espouses ethical collaboration and reflexive methodologies to better understand and represent marginalized communities.

Step-by-step explanation:

Nancy Scheper-Hughes is recognized for her anthropological fieldwork that challenges traditional ethical boundaries. Through her approach of 'good enough ethnography,' Scheper-Hughes advocates for anthropological practices that are not fixated on achieving perfect representation, but rather focus on ethical collaboration with communities. This involves transparent acknowledgment of the inherent problems of history and power within anthropological research. To address such challenges, Scheper-Hughes pushes for reflexive methodologies that incorporate the understanding of various perspectives, especially those from marginalized groups.

Moreover, Scheper-Hughes' work signifies a departure from solely 'studying up'—the investigation of powerful institutions—and involves critically assessing one's own training, methodologies, and the impact of anthropology on the study subjects. Ultimately, her contributions to anthropology stem from a commitment to embodying a research ethic that seeks robust engagement and compassion within the discipline while acknowledging its limitations and the need for continuous reflexive evaluation.

Fieldwork undertaken by anthropologists like Scheper-Hughes often confronts the challenge of representing 'the other'. It raises questions about whether it is possible or ethical to portray an insider's perspective fully, given the vast differences in culture and experience between the researcher and the subjects. Scheper-Hughes' work encourages anthropologists to embrace this challenge, seeking to understand and present the perspectives and realities of different cultures as accurately and respectfully as possible while accepting the challenge as part of the process.

User Bel
by
7.6k points